news




Commission won’t support wind turbines
Published: November 24, 2010
By Jim Ridolphi
Special Correspondent

If the Goochland Planning Commission has anything to say about it, the prospect of operating small wind turbines is not in the countys immediate future.

The panel did not recommend approval of an ordinance change that would have allowed the updated windmills in some zoning districts. Most of the commissioners agreed the expanding technology would not be economically feasible for single-family-owned homes in the Goochland area.

First of all, it came out at the meeting that the county’s elevation is not conducive to the high wind levels needed to generate power.

And County Planner Tom Coleman said his office had not received any requests for a permit to construct one of the monopoles.

The new ordinance would have allowed monopole structures up to 199 feet on private land in zoning districts A-1, A-2, F-C, M-1 and M-2.

Conditional use permits would be required and setbacks are required to be 1.5 times the distance of the height of the tower.

Commissioner Lowe Lunsford said the new ordinance was unnecessary and was “economic insanity.” Fellow commissioner Courtney Hyers agreed and said the use of monopoles could cause a threat to Goochland’s rural view shed.

Other members said there is little likelihood the technology in its current forms would have mass appeal, but said there was no harm in addressing the issue.

Coleman said the proposal was the result of the administration’s and staff’s desire to have ordinances in place when wind turbine requests are received.

In a presentation to the commission, Coleman said “wind and other forms of sustainable energy are increasing in popularity and some citizens want to be energy independent, increase their energy footprint and save money over a long term.”

Commissioner Ty Querry said he supported efforts to explore green energy sources, and said the cost of installing a unit is decreasing and will be available to homeowners through major retailers in the immediate future.

Even the commissioners who supported the measure had questions regarding the proposed height of the towers and the minimum acreage required to construct a turbine.

Other counties have allowed the units, but none have allowed the maximum heights suggested in the proposal.

“We certainly wouldn’t want them in any subdivisions,” Commissioner Bill Neal said. He also said the conditional use process would still give the county rights of refusal for projects that did not meet the criteria.

Lunsford moved for a denial of the recommendation and his co-members agreed. The measure moves forward to the Goochland County Board of Supervisors without the Planning Commission’s approval.

In another matter, staff sought an ordinance change that would extend the period the Planning Commission has to act on a proposal from 60 to 70 days.

That extra time would accommodate calendar irregularities that sometimes make it difficult for the panel to defer matters. Coleman said the ordinance change would “eliminate technical violations.”

The Virginia State Code allows up to 100 days for the action, and some commissioners thought the panel should take advantage of the time allowed.

Hyers urged her colleagues to consider extending the period to the maximum. “Why shouldn’t we go to the 100 days,” she said. “It doesn’t mean we have to take the 100 days, but should we not have the maximum in our ordinance consistent with what Virginia law permits.”

Coleman reminded the panel that the Board of Supervisors sent the proposal forward with the 70-day extension. The panel moved for recommendation of the change as presented.

Goochland County requested a conditional use permit allowing the construction of a communications tower adjacent to the Company 5 Firehouse in the courthouse area.

The new tower would complement a regional communications system and enhance emergency communications in the county.

Coleman said a community meeting was scheduled for later in the week to allow neighbors an opportunity to express their views on the project.

Some commissioners found it unusual that planning staff had not scheduled a community meeting before the application was considered.

“It seems to me the public meeting should have occurred before we met,” Neal said. “It’s not the right way to do things.”

“We acknowledge this hasn’t been handled the way it usually is,” Coleman replied. “The public does have the opportunity to comment prior to final decision on the application.”

A public hearing will be held when the Board of Supervisors considers the proposal at a future meeting.



Reader Comments


Marian Kimball of 4311 Tabscott Pines Road, Columbia, VA  |  Dec. 9, 2010, 11:07 AM

Here’s a system that is now available with a more realistic payback but only for businesses.  It does not address the fact that Virginia is not one of the states that just don’t get enough sun hours to economically participate in the solar market.  But this is interesting because it captures all the waste energy from a system. 


Unique Solar Hybrid System Hits The Market

Whelan estimates a business can eliminate as much as 70-80% of their fossil fuel usage to heat water on an annual basis using his hybrid system. Companies across the board, including large institutions, supermarkets, hotels, hospitals, restaurants, car washes and others, can expect a 2-3 year return on their investment.
by Staff Writers
Stamford CT (SPX) Dec 09, 2010
eco Hybrid Solar is proud to announce that their brand new Hybrid Solar Water Heating System is now available to the market. Three years in the works, the proprietary hybrid system is unique in that it combines the use of two technologies in tandem for water heating at great cost savings to users.
“Solar hot water heating systems have been around for 50 years,” says company owner Gordon Whelan.

“The difference with ours’ is that it’s the only system to maximize the efficiency of existing technologies by integrating solar thermal and recycled waste heat from refrigeration and air conditioning equipment into a one loop/circuit. This otherwise wasted energy is captured and used to heat water in a pre- heat storage tank.”

In today’s tough economy Whelan sees his product playing a critical role in energy and fiscal saving solutions for energy conscious businesses and the HVAC contractors who service them. Because the hybrid system makes use of the waste heat found on location, its’ practical energy savings are immediately higher than a traditional solar water system.

“Our hybrid system increases the “SEER” (seasonal energy efficiency ratio) on air conditioning and refrigeration equipment by as much as 3 SEERs,” says Whelan.

“Technically, the refrigeration equipment is being “water cooled” which in turn means less repair bills due to overheated refrigeration equipment. Additional, benefit of the refrigeration equipment being primarily, “water cooled”, the air conditioning or refrigeration air cooling fan motor’s operation is considerably reduced, thereby saving electricity usage.

Whelan estimates a business can eliminate as much as 70-80% of their fossil fuel usage to heat water on an annual basis using his hybrid system. Companies across the board, including large institutions, supermarkets, hotels, hospitals, restaurants, car washes and others, can expect a 2-3 year return on their investment.

“A typical solar thermal system on its own will take you 7-10 years to get a payback,” he says.

Combining high efficiency heating and cooling systems with a solar system like the Hybrid Solar Water Heating System is a prime opportunity for HVAC contractors. Many customers are looking to take advantage of solar tax credits (installations of solar energy systems before December 2016 are eligible for a no-limit, 30 percent tax credit from the federal government, as well as other rebates that are available from State and local utilities.)

There is also a $1,500 tax credit for high-efficiency heating and cooling systems in place. Contractors who provide both services not only have an opportunity to increase their profits, they can also ensure their customers obtain the best possible levels of comfort and energy savings.

“At eco Hybrid Solar we believe that the day is coming soon when it becomes mandatory to utilize free waste energy wherever it is available and whatever format it comes in; Class 1, 2 or 3 renewable energy,” says Whelan. “An Eco Hybrid Solar Water Heating System is one energy saving way to reduce your ever increasing utility costs.”

The eco Hybrid Solar system is distributed by Diversified Heat Transfer, Inc. (DHT), An engineering and manufacturing company, highly specialized in the design of heat transfer equipment and water heating systems, operating worldwide since 1938. A market leader through quality design and by innovating and developing technology.


Garry Astle of Perth, Western, 6007, Australia  |  Dec. 6, 2010, 01:46 AM

Lowe Lunsford said right. I am agree with you. Thanks ;)


Marietta  |  Nov. 30, 2010, 11:23 PM

This debate will continue to grow as more and more people look for ways to become self sufficient.


rick jarrell of goochland  |  Nov. 29, 2010, 10:31 AM

If its on his property more power to him . pun intended . sounds like he is a frontiersman in this industry and we need this type of energy . if its not cost effective is really not your business . unless of course you have to pay the bill . 
  government has no business telling me where and when i can build a turbine or solar panels . as long as it is a safe structure meeting building code and within the borders of my property . why should anyone be denied the right to become more self sufficent ? this whole idea that government can prevent me from heating and lighting my home is ludicrus .


Marian Kimball of 4311 Tabscott Pines Road, Columbia, VA  |  Nov. 27, 2010, 02:06 PM

Goochland County approved a large solar panel installation without having any idea what it looked like or the amount of space it took up.  This came to light after Mr. Carchman installed his facility.  I think you should ban all solar installations as well unless they are roof top installed since you are not taking the time to fully evaluate what is going on.  Solar installastions take up a huge amount of space, they are unsightly as well as wind turbins and neither are economical at this time anywhere in Virginia.


Page 1 of 1 pages


Submit Your Comments Below

Name: (Required)

Email: (Required)

Location:

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?

Submit the word you see below:



By clicking submit, you agree to our terms and conditions.

Deal of the Day